Learning how to answer medical case study questions starts with a simple habit: before you write your answer, sort the clues by what they do. Some details support an explanation, some weaken it, and some leave you wishing the case had told you more. An evidence table gives each kind of clue a place. It also helps you avoid a common mistake: treating a finding the prompt never mentions as if someone checked for it and found nothing.
Read the question before you sort the case. If it asks for the most likely explanation, your job is to compare possibilities, not to prove one beyond doubt. If it asks for a missing finding that would help, name the finding and explain how it would change your answer. Set up the table around the specific explanation you are testing. A detail cannot count as evidence for or against until you say what it is evidence for or against.
Not every detail needs a spot. If two explanations fit a clue equally well, it may add context without helping you choose. In a written exercise, you can leave out that clue rather than force it into a column. Likewise, an empty evidence-against column is acceptable if the case gives no finding that clearly weakens your leading explanation. Do not invent one just to fill the space.
A 16-year-old reports a runny nose, repeated sneezing, and itchy, watery eyes. These symptoms have started shortly after several outdoor soccer practices over the past two weeks and eased after the student went indoors. The student reports no fever. The prompt does not describe what happens on days without outdoor practice.
Which better explains the symptoms: allergic rhinitis or a common cold? Give the strongest reason and identify one missing detail that would help you compare them.
Allergic rhinitis is a reaction to allergens such as pollen. It can cause sneezing, a runny nose, and itchy, watery eyes, as described by MedlinePlus in its overview of allergic rhinitis. A common cold can also cause a runny nose and sneezing. If you circle only those two symptoms, you have noticed real clues, but you have not yet found a good reason to favor one explanation. Look at what accompanies the nasal symptoms and when they recur.
| Explanation | Evidence for | Evidence against | Information still missing |
|---|---|---|---|
| Allergic rhinitis | Itchy, watery eyes fit an allergy. Symptoms repeatedly start after outdoor practice and ease indoors, a pattern consistent with exposure to an outdoor allergen. | No finding given clearly weakens this explanation. | Are symptoms absent on days without outdoor practice? That would help show whether they track outdoor exposure. |
| Common cold | A runny nose and sneezing fit a cold, but they also fit allergic rhinitis. | Repeated symptoms after outdoor practice with improvement indoors are less consistent with one ongoing cold. | Do symptoms continue between practices, including on days spent indoors? A more continuous pattern would weaken the argument based on outdoor exposure. |
The same timing clue appears in both rows because it supports one explanation while weakening the other. That does not make it two independent pieces of evidence. Nor should you pick the row with the most entries. A pattern that separates the two explanations can carry more weight than several symptoms they share.
Notice what happened to the fever detail. The student reports no fever, so it is a stated negative, not missing information. But a cold can occur without fever, so that detail does little to settle this comparison. By contrast, the case says nothing about symptoms on days without outdoor practice. You cannot write that the student feels fine on those days. You can only say how knowing that would affect your reasoning.
Start with your choice. Follow it with the most useful comparison, then give the missing detail the question asks for. You do not need to copy every cell. In this case, the timing does the most work, and the itchy eyes add support.
Allergic rhinitis is more likely than a common cold because symptoms repeatedly start after outdoor practice and ease indoors, a pattern that fits exposure to an outdoor allergen better than a continuous cold. The itchy, watery eyes also support an allergy. I would ask whether symptoms are absent on days without outdoor practice, because that would strengthen the link to outdoor exposure.
The answer says more likely, not confirmed. It also avoids naming pollen as the definite trigger. The setting suggests outdoor exposure, but the case never identifies the substance involved. Keep that distinction when you write: the observation is that symptoms follow practice; the inference is that an outdoor allergen may explain the pattern.
Try the method on a case from the IMedC training and practice problems, or look for study materials on the IMedC learning resources page.
On your first pass, jot down any clue that might matter. Then underline the clue that best separates your leading explanation from its closest alternative. Cross out repeated points and details that do not help answer the question. As a final check, put a finger on each claim in your written answer and find the exact words in the prompt that support it. If you cannot point to those words, label the claim as an inference or turn it into a question for the missing-information column.
Do I need to hand in the evidence table?
Follow the prompt. If it asks for a short written answer, use the table as scratch work and submit the reasoning the question requests.
Can the same clue go in two rows?
Yes. One clue can support one explanation and weaken another, but it is still a single finding.
What if there is no evidence against my answer?
Leave that cell blank or write that the case gives no clear evidence against it. That does not mean the explanation is confirmed.
About the International Medicine Competition: an online medicine competition for high school students from around the world. Qualification Round 2027: submissions are open until Sunday, 7 February 2027. How the rounds work